Songwriting is not the same as poetry….. It is totally different. There is a beat in both, but the poet has much more room to wiggle in than the song writer does.
Frugality with words has never been my strongest point and so I have always levitated toward poetry. The reason for that is if I can’t drive my point home in the first stanza, then I’ve got three or four more stanzas to make up for that. The song writer really doesn’t have that luxury because basically his story needs to be told in one stanza, maybe with a repeating chorus. It needs to be short, sweet and to the point.
The ear and the eye are two completely different organs. I think that may explain why some of our teenagers, the most imaginative and creative people among us, tend to text conversations more so than phoning them. Flowery and depth in the written word can capture the reader, but those same words can be absorbed completely differently by the ear, which – as we know from Pavlonian training through every conversation we have ever had, is expected to be unscripted, and unencumbered with depth.
Song writers like John Lennon and Paul McCartney were prolific. They could write songs in their sleep. “I want to hold your hand.” In written form it is very simple and direct, and let’s face it, completely boring. Even as a classical poet I have absolutely little use for such an obvious statement. But now let’s flip the 45 on the record player a moment and change it to “Ahhh wannnaaa hooooooolllllllddddddd yoooooooorrrrrrrrr Haaa-eeeee-yahhhh-eeeee-yahhhh-eeeeeee-annnnnnnnnnddddd” and suddenly it becomes a completely different monster which was so popular that it almost single handedly changed an entire generation’s view of music.
Other writers, like Jimmy Hendrix and Jim Croce found an amazing correlation between the two, which I think is uncommon. And so incredibly beautiful.
It’s important to challenge oneself, and this is my challenge at songwriting.
A Song For Who I used to Be
(when you were with me)
Memories so far away
distance keeps our lives at bay.
At sixteen years lived a boy in me,
who died yesterday.
And your eyes -
Slowly fade Away -
Away from yesterday.
How long can a memory last?
Longer than your heartfelt grasp
How strong can a memory be?
When your eyes were looking at me?
A different world sings a different song.
A different time and my life seems gone.
After sixteen -
I don’t -
belong.
At sixteen years lived a boy in me,
who died yesterday.
And your eyes -
Slowly fade Away -
Away from yesterday.
.
.
|
Every time I tried to tell you |
||
|
The words just came out wrong |
||
|
So I had to say I love you |
||
|
In a song. |
||
|
-Jim Croce |


